Failing grade for uni's overseas courses
By Aban Contractor
August 6 2003
Macquarie University failed to ensure that students enrolled in its overseas
courses passed entry requirements, including speaking English, an audit
report has found.
The university watchdog, the Australian Universities Quality Agency,
investigated four pro-grams run by Macquarie in China and Singapore and
found evidence of "unacceptable practice".
With the overseas student market now worth $5.2 billion a year to Australia,
the report, which is released today, will send shockwaves throughout the
higher education sector.
The report said students had enrolled full-time in the Macquarie University
Bachelor of Business Administration course at the Times Management Institute
in Singapore from 2000, but Macquarie did not know of their existence until
April 2002.
Students, who each paid $19,500 for the three-year course, had not been
approved by the university nor entered into the university's student
administration system.
"Students advised the delegation that they had no contact whatsoever with
Macquarie until September 2002, despite being clear that they were enrolled
in the Macquarie University BBA," the report said. "In October 2002 they
received their first Macquarie student ID cards."
The general manager of Macquarie International, Tony Adams, was surprised at
the university's poor report. "I think AUQA got it wrong," he said
yesterday.
Macquarie University realised there were "some administrative problems with
the program" in early 2002 and employed a consultant to investigate.
"We got that report in July 2002 and these issues were dealt with,"
Professor Adams said. "It was all fixed up by September of last year and
used as a basis for new contract discussions."
The watchdog's executive director, David Woodhouse, commended Macquarie for
handing in a copy of the consultant's report, but said the university still
needed to act.
"It was too long between it happening and the university picking it up," Dr
Woodhouse said. "It was a partner of the university acting on its own
initiative, but in the university's name. We recommend Macquarie
significantly improve their monitoring processes."
A spokesman for the federal Education Minister said the Government had
committed additional resources to investigate more overseas education
programs.
The watchdog report also criticised Macquarie's Master of Economics program
at Nanjing Normal University in China.
Macquarie set the entry standards for the course, which cost students $4000,
and issued all those enrolled Macquarie ID cards. However, many of the
students did not speak English.
"Students have the choice of submitting assignments and exam scripts in
English or Chinese. This raises the question of availability of appropriate
staff to assess and moderate written work," the report said.
"In class, translation is provided by one of the students, placing a
considerable burden on that student during class time and raising issues
about the student's ability to provide an accurate translation service."
The watchdog praised Maquarie's Master of Applied Finance program at the
Singapore Human Resources Institute as professionally managed. However, it
said electives were often withdrawn because not enough students enrolled and
the institute set its own rules for invigilating exams.
This story was found at:
www.smh.com.au/articles/2003/08/05/1060064185052.html--
Sharon Smith
Administrative Executive Officer
========================
National Liaison Committee
for International Students in Australia Inc.
Suite 64, Trades Hall
54 Victoria Street
Carlton South
VIC 3053
Telephone 03 9650 8908
Mobile 0422 398 679
Fax 03 9650 8906
Email. isd@nus.asn.au